By Oct. 1, 2026, Woodcliff Lake had to make the first of two $147,500 payments to the owners of the former Hilton at 200 Tice Boulevard. According to Pascack Press, the money settles a tax refund of about $295,000 for tax years 2018 through 2024, approved 5-0 by the Borough Council on July 20. The second payment is due by Oct. 1, 2027.
That refund is the clearest way to understand why a borough known for single-family streets under heavy tree cover is about to add roughly 670 homes on four sites. Most of them will be townhomes, apartments and stacked flats. If you're comparing Pascack Valley towns, the borough is changing in ways the current sales data can't show you yet.
Empty campuses send their tax bills back
Commercial property in a small borough supports the local budget. When the companies inside it leave, the owners go to the Tax Court of New Jersey and argue that the buildings are worth less. They usually win something. The Hilton refund covers seven years.
The former BMW North America campus at 300 Chestnut Ridge Road was the bigger risk. In December 2025, Pascack Press reported that Mayor Carlos Rendo said BMW's pending tax appeals, totaling more than $13 million, would have caused serious fiscal trouble for the borough without a negotiated agreement with the site's new developer. In the same report, Councilwoman Jennifer Margolis said no one wanted to see BMW, Hilton or Party City close and leave town, "but it happened."
When the Hilton settlement was approved, Rendo explained the reasoning to Pascack Press:
"It's a good settlement. It reflects the realities of commercial property values throughout the state. As corporate space dies out, the state is mandating affordable housing. It's the reality now."
His quote ties the two pressures together. The office market drove the value of these parcels down at the same time the state was asking towns to plan for more homes. For land like this, residential redevelopment became the realistic use.
The state set a number, and the borough negotiated the density
New Jersey's Fourth Round of affordable housing runs from July 1, 2025, through June 30, 2035. The borough's adopted Fourth Round Housing Element and Fair Share Plan says that in October 2024, the state Department of Community Affairs published a non-binding estimate putting Woodcliff Lake's prospective need at 423 units. The borough declared 329 in January 2025. After mediation with Fair Share Housing Center, both sides agreed on 360, and a Superior Court order on May 13, 2025, set the obligation at 360 prospective units and zero present need.
A borough with little vacant land isn't expected to build all 360. Its March 2026 plan amendment sets a "realistic development potential" of 131 units. That figure started at 66 in the June 2025 plan and was raised after Fair Share Housing Center challenged it. The remaining 229 units are "unmet need," and the borough must still create a realistic opportunity for at least 58 of them.
Because affordable units are usually built as a share of larger mixed-income projects, a 131-unit target can mean several hundred homes in total. This is also why the borough wanted the deals done on its own terms. Council President Joshua Stern told Pascack Press that one developer first suggested 600 to 700 units on the BMW site, and that eight months of negotiation brought the plan down to 370. He said developers statewide are increasingly using affordable-housing statutes to propose dense housing. When a borough has an obligation and an empty campus, negotiating usually leads to fewer units than waiting for a developer's proposal.
The PILOT changes who carries the bill
The BMW site agreement includes a payment in lieu of taxes, or PILOT. Under it, the borough receives 10% to 15% of annual gross revenues from the apartments over 30 years, and a separate 20-year PILOT covers the townhouses. Officials project slightly more than $106 million for Woodcliff Lake over 30 years. A modified redevelopment agreement adds up-front payments before regular PILOT revenue starts, which Pascack Press said is likely to happen around project completion in about 2030.
In the same Pascack Press report, officials said the PILOT could help stabilize municipal taxes. Special counsel Wendy Quiroga said the payments would not reduce school funding, because school districts adopt and fund their own budgets. About 20 residents raised concerns at the December 2025 hearing, some about how quickly the full agreement was made public. If you're weighing a purchase, look at both sides. The redevelopment is meant to replace revenue the old campuses were losing through appeals, and it's still a long contract that a future council will have to manage.
Four sites, one with construction underway
Here is where each project stands heading into mid-November 2026.
| Site | Former use | Planned homes | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| 300 Chestnut Ridge Road | BMW North America HQ | 370, including 74 affordable | Broke ground Oct. 8, 2026 |
| 200 Tice Boulevard | Hilton hotel | 147, including 30 affordable | Redevelopment plan adopted March 16, 2026 |
| 100 Tice Boulevard | Party City | Up to 91, with at least 18 affordable | Overlay ordinance adopted March 16, 2026 |
| 240, 258 and 264 Broadway | Existing lots | 63, including at least 12 affordable | Redevelopment plan adopted March 16, 2026 |
The BMW site is now under construction as Orchard House by Vermella, a partnership of Russo Development and Woodmont Properties operating as RW Woodcliff Lake Urban Renewal LLC. NJBIZ reported a mix of 297 apartments, 47 townhomes and 26 supportive housing units on 21 acres. The plan also includes about 9,000 square feet of retail, a new public park and a walking trail around the property's edge, with about half the campus left as open space. NorthJersey.com covered the Oct. 8 groundbreaking ahead of time.
The Tice Boulevard sites come next in the pipeline. Short Hills-based Garden Homes bought the former Hilton at auction in early 2024 for $50.7 million. In August 2026, Pascack Press reported that a formal proposal for the 21-acre site had not yet come before the Land Use Board. The adopted plan allows apartments, townhomes, manor townhomes and stacked flats, with a 20% affordable-housing requirement.
The former Party City site next door came out of a settlement with SIG 100 Tice LLC, which the council approved in December 2025. Pascack Press described the mix as 73 market-rate townhouses and 18 age-restricted affordable apartments. Ordinance 26-04, which creates the overlay, describes up to 91 units, including 25 market-rate age-targeted townhouses and commercial space. Its affordable-housing standard is a minimum of 18 units or 20% of the total, so a full 91-unit build would need at least 19 affordable homes.
On Broadway, the Land Use Board's February 2026 minutes describe a three-phase project of townhomes and stacked townhomes. Under adopted plans, the three projects without construction underway still need site-plan approval from the Land Use Board before any work can begin.
What this means for a buyer comparing towns
The current picture of Woodcliff Lake comes mostly from detached-home sales. Over the next several years, the borough will also have a different kind of housing stock along Chestnut Ridge Road and Tice Boulevard. That includes rental apartments, townhomes with their own 20-year PILOT, stacked flats and manor townhomes, and age-targeted townhomes. Woodcliff Lake has had few of these in any number.
That matters to three kinds of buyers we work with:
- First-time buyers and downsizers who want a Woodcliff Lake address without the maintenance of a detached house will have more options later in the decade. If you need to move in 2027, though, you're still choosing mostly from existing homes.
- Move-up families buying near Chestnut Ridge Road or Tice Boulevard should expect several years of construction nearby. When it's done, they'll have a public park, a perimeter trail and new retail space on what used to be a fenced corporate campus.
- Investors should know that Orchard House's apartments are planned as rentals. Until they're finished, they won't affect local rent comparisons.
The fiscal reason for all of this is the one Rendo gave. Commercial values were falling and the state required housing, so the borough negotiated the number of homes and the payment terms instead of continuing to pay appeal refunds. Orchard House is the first project under construction, and the borough expects regular PILOT revenue around 2030.
This post explains how the borough's agreements and housing plan work. It isn't legal, tax or financial advice, so check how any of it applies to your own purchase with your attorney or tax professional.
FAQ
Is all of the new housing in Woodcliff Lake affordable housing? No. Of the 370 homes at Orchard House, 74 are designated affordable, including 26 supportive housing units. The 200 Tice plan has 30 affordable homes out of 147, and the 100 Tice overlay requires at least 18 affordable homes, or 20% of the total if that is greater, in a project of up to 91.
Why didn't the borough just keep these sites commercial? The owners were winning tax reductions as office and hotel values fell, and the state required the borough to plan for 360 prospective affordable units. Residential redevelopment addressed both problems.
When will the Orchard House homes be finished? Pascack Press reported that regular PILOT payments are expected to begin near project completion, which officials estimated at around 2030.
If you're deciding between a detached house in Woodcliff Lake now and one of the townhome or flat options coming later in the decade, The Ramundo Team can go through the timing with you, including which streets are near the Chestnut Ridge Road and Tice Boulevard sites and how those projects fit your move. Schedule a consultation and we'll look at it together.